Published on:

Prosecutor Files Lawsuit Against Judge Over Handling of Out-of-State DUI Case

Judges and prosecutors have distinct roles in the criminal justice system, and generally, they refrain from exercising powers outside of the scope of their authority. If they do overstep their bounds, however, it may lead to unexpected outcomes. For example, a prosecutor in North Dakota recently sued a judge, arguing that the judge violated the separation of powers by refusing to approve a plea deal that would have ignored one of the defendant’s prior DUI convictions. The lawsuit, which alleges that defendants convicted of fourth DUIs are subject to less stringent penalties than those convicted of third DUIs, seeks to remedy a perceived injustice. If you are charged with a third or subsequent DUI offense, it is smart to meet with a knowledgeable Illinois DUI defense attorney to assess your rights.

The North Dakota Case

It is reported that the North Dakota legislature recently increased the penalties for repeat DUI offenders. Specifically, a person convicted of a third DUI, which is a class A misdemeanor, faces a 120-day jail sentence, while a person convicted of a fourth DUI crime, which is a Class C felony, may be imprisoned for one year and one day. The prosecutor alleges that, essentially, sentences for fourth DUIs are paper penalties, in that parties convicted of such offenses spend significantly less time in prison than those convicted of lesser crimes.

Allegedly, the prosecutor attempted to subvert the sentencing deficiencies by entering into a plea agreement with a defendant that would have reduced the number of the defendant’s prior DUI convictions, which would have resulted in a lesser sentence on paper but arguably more time in prison. When the judge refused to adopt the plea agreement, the prosecution filed suit, arguing the judge violated the separation of powers.

Sentencing for DUI Crimes in Illinois

As in most states, Illinois imposes increased penalties for people convicted of repeat DUI crimes. The precise penalties imposed will vary depending on the facts of the case, such as the defendant’s BAC level at the time the crime was allegedly committed, whether anyone was injured, and whether the defendant was transporting any minors at the time of the offense. Generally, though, second DUIs are charged as misdemeanors, and a person convicted of a second DUI faces a minimum sentence of up to five days imprisonment or 240 hours of community service. Third and subsequent DUI offenses are charged as felonies. In some instances, first or second DUI crimes as well, depending on numerous factors. Felony DUI convictions in Illinois can result in significant prison sentences, that increase with each subsequent offense.

Speak to an Experienced DUI Defense Attorney

A conviction for a third or subsequent DUI offense can carry significant penalties, and it is wise for anyone charged with such crimes to understand their rights. Theodore J. Harvatin, of Harvatin Law Offices, PC, is an experienced Illinois DUI defense attorney with the skills and resources needed to defend people faced with DUI charges, and if you hire him, he will work tirelessly on your behalf. You can contact Mr. Harvatin through the form online or at 217.525.0520 to schedule a conference.

Contact Information